Skip to main content

CD, or not CD?

... that is the question!

I read an entertaining blogpost the other day from @restructuregirl, who was having a wee bit of a rant about obsolescence.  To summarise a rather first world problem, after much research into the various quirks and largely baffling features of new TV's she eventually settled on a selection to soon discover that the very feature she wanted had been made obsolete in the latest models.  What a total pain in the arse.  Tying it all back to the library sphere, she pointed out that we should really plan for obsolescence in our industry. I have to say I agree; particularly when you consider the speed at which anything related to information use and storage (i.e. our entire industry) is changing.

This got me thinking of another article I read ages ago about how a small group of engineers had to laboriously reverse engineer machinery capable of reading super high-res pictures taken by lunar satellites in the 1960's:

Lost lunar photos recovered by great feats of hackerdom

The tapes on which these pictures were stored were close to being thrown away, until this small group of dedicated engineers and hackers worked tirelessly to recreate machines capable of reading their contents. In so doing, they were able to "rediscover" phenomenal pictures of the moon and lunar landing sites that would have otherwise been tossed. If it wasn't for this group of enthusiasts these very important pictures may have been left to slowly decay in landfill.  Did the NASA archivist at the time think these pictures were not worth saving, or was obsolescence not a big issue in the 60's?

And what the hell does this have to do with CDs?

The discussions on obsolescence has made me think of the ongoing relevance of CDs in the library. Other than dearly wishing numerous Justin Bieber CDs to the aforementioned decaying landfill fate, I am left to wonder whether more worthy musical experiences will soon suffer the same ignoble end. We had a library expert guy come through a couple of months ago talking about how to cull the collection (we are renovating, and need to weed about 30%).  His biggest suggestion was to "be bold" and ditch the CDs (and the magazines - but that's a whole other discussion) as they are old formats. Ditch the CD's, eh?  I wasn't sure if I agreed quite yet.  We place our CD's into genres and although I could see the Rock/Pop and Dance being the first to leave (with the more tech-savvy listener base already tuned in to streaming) I wasn't so sure about the Jazz/Blues and Classical, or the World Music.  I had a chat with one of my musician mates and she still produces CDs because she is a jazz musician - her fan base are the older folk who like to listen to CDs in their car.  If we ditch all our CDs, will we be doing a large portion of our patrons a disservice?  Or will we force them to hurry up and move with the times?  And what about people who can't afford fancy smartphones with big download limits, or maybe aren't up with the play on Spotify or Pandora or Apple Music?  Is it our job to drag them into the 21st century?

Even though I have access to streaming services and use them quite often, I also pick up a lot of CDs from work.  When I'm shelving I'll spot something that grabs my attention and borrow it - taking a chance on artists I know nothing about.  It's completely free and just so much easier to browse and discover new material when it's right in front of you. I rarely do the same with streaming services, even their "Discover" options act more like a radio replacement than a true introduction to new artists. I guess the primary purpose of a library isn't to act as a discovery service for artists or authors (or is it?) but it is definitely a niche that we fill well.

Questions, questions, questions (and this post has kind of meandered off track) but I guess my biggest point is - should libraries lead the way in the changing face of technology, or be the ones to hold on to it for that little bit longer, particularly as we are supposed to be catering for everyone?  Is it feasible for us to have the old and new at the same time, or should we just keep our focus on the future?


Popular posts from this blog

Using librarian skills to uncover a network of dodgy shopping sites!

In all my posts over the years I'm not sure if I ever mentioned I am an avid steampunker.  Like many of my quirky fellow librarians, I love a good dress up and recently found myself searching for a great pair of boots to go with the Steampunk Aviator Superhero costume I'm assembling (trust me, it will work!).

One evening whilst idly thumbing through Pinterest I found a picture of these undeniably AWESOME combat-boot style boots.  I followed the link to the website ( and although it didn't look dodgy and offered PayPal, I am a cautious online shopper and always check the customer reviews first.  They were 1000% abysmal.  Like the kind of reviews that say SCAM, THEFT and CAN I LEAVE 0 STARS.  So despite loving the shoes, I was definitely not parting with my money on this occasion.

Fast forward a couple of months and I see an ad for Victorian-style cosplay boots in my Insta feed.  Did I mention that I am an avid steampunker?  Because seriously, these shoes…

It only takes a second (ment)

What the hell is a secondment?
Some people I have chatted to have no idea what I'm talking about (and I also discovered that some spell-check utilities don't even recognise the word) so I thought I would clear the confusion by ripping a definition straight from Merriam-Webster:
Definition of secondmentplural-s

: the detachment of a person (such as a military officer) from his or her regular organization for temporary assignment elsewhere.

So if you just substitute "library services officer" for "military officer" you have an explanation of my situation!

Being a qualified Librarian can take you in so many different directions. One of the reasons I chose the tag "Ambidextrous Librarian" was because I honestly had no idea which direction my career would go. I have worked in school libraries and the kids and teachers are absolutely fantastic, but the pay, conditions and options for career development aren't all that varied. I tri…

A Somewhat Risky Business

Working in a public library means I am surrounded all day by books (duh).  Books are such pretty things - there is a reason why publishers spend big bucks on cover design, and that's because we pretty much ignore the old "don't judge a book by its cover" and happily judegy-judge away.  We can't help it, bright and shiny things attract us!

So as I was standing at the circ desk the other day having a bit of a rest between patrons, I found my eyes drawn yet again to a book that was on display.  I had been gazing at it on and off all day, and I couldn't really make out the title but it was the dress that caught me, and the shiny peach converse trainers, and the pose, and the luxurious hair.  I decided that the universe was telling me I had to borrow it, even if I had absolutely no idea what it was about.  I took it home without even reading the blurb.

The book was titled "This is just my face; try not to stare" by Gabourey Sidibe, the actress who starr…